Superfreakonomics By Steven D. Levitt And Stephen J. Dubner – Book Review
Superfreakonomics by Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner reminds me of the series of entertaining mysteries by Sue Grafton: A is for Alibi, B is for Burglar, C is for Corpse-with titles all the way to Z. Which makes me wonder where will the two authors of Superfreakonomics end milking the title?
While the first book Freakonomics was fresh, irreverent, informative, and filled with serious research, the sequel is short of exploitative. Telling and exposing human foibles is fine except when some of the exposition is presented as scientific research; much of it unrigorous. Despite the fact that economics is still labeled the “dismal science,” there’s really no advantage in mocking it to irrelevancy. I wonder what Paul Krugman and other Nobel economic prize winners think of this infamous sequel.
Sequels often disappoint and this one is more than a disappointment-it’s an undisguised effort to cash in on the success of the first book, which I understand sold over 4 million copies.
The authors pick up a counterintuitive statement and proceed to show the world how foolish people are in believing much nonsense. This is the magic formula. This is their angle. For example they would like to convince you that prostitutes are patriotic. Go figure! They would like to persuade you that taming hurricanes and typhoons is a benign idea; but even sixth graders know about the balance of nature and the Butterfly Effect. A butterfly flapping its wings has far-reaching effects in eco-systems. Yet they seem to like tinkering with geo-engineering.
Blogger Tim Lambert reports the following:
One of the injured parties is Ken Caldeira, a climate scientist at Stanford University who is quoted (accurately) as saying that “we are being incredibly foolish emitting carbon dioxide.” Then Dubner and Levitt add this astonishing claim: “His research tells him that carbon dioxide is not the right villain in this fight.”
That’s provocative, but alas, it isn’t true. Caldeira, like the vast majority of climate scientists, believes cutting carbon dioxide and other greenhouse-gas emissions is our only real chance to avoid runaway climate change.
“Carbon dioxide is the right villain,” Caldeira wrote on his Web site in reply. He told Joe Romm, the respected climate blogger who broke the story, that he had objected to the “wrong villain” line but Dubner and Levitt didn’t correct it; instead, they added the “incredibly foolish” quote, a half step in the right direction. Caldeira gave the same account to me.
And the controversy rages on. When newspapers report incorrect facts, they issue apologies and corrections immediately. Shouldn’t Dubner and Levitt issue an apology to Caldeira and possibly insert an errata note in future printings of Superfreakonomics? That would be the sensible thing to do. We shall see.
In Freakonomics they aggravated teachers by commenting on supposedly teacher-led cheating on pupil standardized tests. In the sequel the authors submit that teachers should be paid more. Are they trying to atone for their early sin?
More and more climate science experts are criticizing the book for many misleading statements and the inclusion of discredited arguments. What we have in this book is a hodgepodge of weird facts, many of which are only tangentially related to economic theory.
Superfreakonomics is not only aimless and disjointed, but also tedious.
When Susan Grafton publishes a new title –let’s say, SS is for Sap– I buy it right away because it amuses me to read her fiction. Now the next time Dubner and Levitt bring out another sequel –let’s say Incrediblesuperfreakonomics– it will not amuse anyone.
About the Author
Retired. Former investment banker, Columbia University-educated, Vietnam Vet (67-68).
For the writing techniques I use, see Mary Duffy’s e-book: Sentence Openers.
To read my book reviews of the Classics visit my blog: Writing To Live
|
|
Sheet of 21 Personalised Glossy Stickers or Labels Mucha Alphonse Moravian Teachers Choir £2.49 A sheet of 21 address labels or stickers fully personalised to your own details. Each sticker is approximately 6.35cm x 3.81cm in size. Add your address/message during checkout in the message box provided or email it after the order is placed. Check all spellings and layouts as the information you leave will be copied directly to the sticker for production. The first image is the one to be used o… |
|
|
Sheet of 21 Personalised Glossy Stickers or Labels Dore Gustave 25 My teacher sage aware thrusting him back -Away down there to th- other dogs- £2.49 A sheet of 21 address labels or stickers fully personalised to your own details. Each sticker is approximately 6.35cm x 3.81cm in size. Add your address/message during checkout in the message box provided or email it after the order is placed. Check all spellings and layouts as the information you leave will be copied directly to the sticker for production. The first image is the one to be used o… |
|
|
Quotations Woody Allen Teachers Sheet of 21 Personalised Glossy Stickers or Labels £2.49 A sheet of 21 address labels or stickers fully personalised to your own details. Each sticker is approximately 6.35cm x 3.81cm in size. Add your address/message during checkout in the message box provided or email it after the order is placed. Check all spellings and layouts as the information you leave will be copied directly to the sticker for production. The first image is the one to be used o… |
|
|
SPECIAL OFFER 2 Reward Packs (516 Stickers) 216 Star Reward Stickers 30mm Dia + 300 Gold Stars A Fantastic Way To Reward Children The Best Looking Guaranteed Quality £6.50 ** 2 REWARD PACKS** Reward Stickers Guaranteed Quality Or Your Money Back These are the BEST on the market that’s a promise these labels have not been printed by a colour laser printer, these are full colour ink printed A Super Star Way To Reward Children These stickers are a fun way of rewarding children. |
|
|
Children at War: World War 2 replica Memorabilia Pack (Resources for Teaching – World War 2) £4.20 This replica pack includes: Iconic Childs Evacuee name tag: A replica of an actual Evacuee tag issued by London City Council (14.5cm x 7cm)-Newspaper from 1941:An 8 page replica of the Childrens Newspaper from 1941 aimed at children with Hungry minds. (21cm x 29.5cm) — Ministry of Food War Cooking Leaflet: Puddings and Sweets, people were not encouraged to eat puddings during the war, due to sh… |
|
|
Phil Gordon’s Little Green Book $8.09 As the resident expert and cohost of Celebrity Poker Showdown, Phil has quickly become one of the most sought-after teachers of No Limit Texas Hold’em…. |
|
|
Legendary Labels: Motown Records $9.86 Greg Edwards reveals the magic of Motown, with interviews from Michael Jackson and Smokey Robinson, as part of Legendary Labels… |
|
|
The Crazy School: Madeline Dare, Book 2 (Unabridged) $8.89 Behind the ornate gates of the academy, a teacher finds a disturbing realm where students and teachers must follow the dean’s bizarre therapies…. |
|
|
The Teachers’ Lounge (Unabridged) $7.99 The Teachers’ Lounge is Bill Harley’s newest spoken word recording: a collection of hilarious and dead-on observations about life in elementary school…. |
|
|
Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings $24.07 New – Updated to reflect the most recent developments in the field, this text presents the skills necessary for teachers to assist infants, young children, and their families to meet their special challenges and to develop to their fullest potential. “Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings” takes a noncategorical approach that recognizes special needs, rather than special labels, and provides practical, developmentally appropriate, activity based curriculum adaptat |
|
|
Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings $32.98 New – Updated to reflect the most recent developments in the field, this text presents the skills necessary for teachers to assist infants, young children, and their families to meet their special challenges and to develop to their fullest potential. “Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings” takes a noncategorical approach that recognizes special needs, rather than special labels, and provides practical, developmentally appropriate, activity based curriculum adaptat |
|
|
Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings $5.06 Used – Updated to reflect the most recent developments in the field, this text presents the skills necessary for teachers to assist infants, young children, and their families to meet their special challenges and to develop to their fullest potential. “Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings” takes a noncategorical approach that recognizes special needs, rather than special labels, and provides practical, developmentally appropriate, activity based curriculum adapta |
|
|
Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings $107.4 New – Updated to reflect the most recent developments in the field, this text presents the skills necessary for teachers to assist infants, young children, and their families to meet their special challenges and to develop to their fullest potential. “Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings” takes a noncategorical approach that recognizes special needs, rather than special labels, and provides practical, developmentally appropriate, activity based curriculum adaptat |
|
|
Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings $73.41 New – Updated to reflect the most recent developments in the field, this text presents the skills necessary for teachers to assist infants, young children, and their families to meet their special challenges and to develop to their fullest potential. “Adapting Early Childhood Curricula for Children in Inclusive Settings” takes a noncategorical approach that recognizes special needs, rather than special labels, and provides practical, developmentally appropriate, activity based curriculum adaptat |